Blog

Donuts Aren't an Incentive. Give Drivers Something That Matters.

Food says thank you for being here. A real incentive is money, a prize, or a tool a driver can take home. After proper training, that is how you keep good work going.

I heard it on the floor again: if there are no in-van camera violations for three days, the team gets free donuts. I understand the spirit. Somebody is trying to say thank you. But that is not an incentive.

Food is complimentary. You bring donuts to say thank you for being here. An incentive is monetary. It is a prize. It is something a driver can take home and actually use, like equipment or a tool. Give them something that matters.

I care about this as a person, not as someone looking for a fight with owners. I have been through a lot of DSPs and other third-party shops, and in every one I have taken something worth keeping. Some already run incentives well and then struggle somewhere else. Some take great care of culture and still leave this piece thin. If they sat down and learned from each other — if they built what I think of as a Megazord, each strength locked into the next — this work could be more united and more functional than it is. It does not have to be dystopian all the time.

The Logistics Master is independent of Amazon. I am not writing this to endorse a platform. I am writing it because I have seen people asked to be elite, then thanked with a box of pastries.

It works almost like a game

I am a man who appreciates incentives, because the best ones feel like a fair game. Hey, you do a good job for me, I am going to bless you. That might be a hundred dollars every two weeks, or two hundred, or a pot, a prize, a raffle — something people can look forward to and actually use. The point is not to entice or manipulate anyone. It is to motivate people who already want to be excellent, and to help them keep doing good work.

What the brain does with a reward

Midbrain dopamine neurons do not simply fire because a reward arrived. They fire when the reward is better than expected. In research led by Wolfram Schultz, those neurons were activated by rewards that were better than predicted, stayed near baseline when a reward was exactly as predicted, and were depressed when a predicted reward was omitted. That difference is called a reward prediction error, and it is one of the signals the brain uses to learn which actions are worth repeating.

That is why a routine perk fades. Once everyone knows that three clean camera days means donuts on Thursday, the brain has predicted the donuts. The treat can still be a kindness. It is no longer a spark. If the donuts fail to show up, you may hear more disappointment than thanks. The expected reward has started to feel like an entitlement.

Variable or unexpected rewards work differently. Schultz and colleagues later found that dopamine neurons also carry a signal related to uncertainty, strongest when the odds of a reward are most open. A raffle, a rotating prize, or a bonus that is earned but not clockwork will usually hold attention longer than a perk people have already counted on.

Reward is the ethical lever

There is an old shorthand from the intelligence world for what moves a person, called MICE: Money, Ideology, Compromise (sometimes listed as Coercion), and Ego. I first heard a close version of it as reward, idea, coercion, and ego. Writing in the CIA journal Studies in Intelligence, Randy Burkett described the Cold War mnemonic as money, ideology, blackmail, or ego.

I mention it to be precise, then to draw a hard line. In a workplace, coercion has no place. The ethical levers are reward and recognition, offered after real training to people who take pride in the work. Money and a prize speak to reward. Being named, thanked in front of the team, or chosen as Driver of the Month speaks to being seen. Ideology, here, is closer to craft: the drive to be elite and to do the job right. When a person runs on reward after proper training, you have a formula.

Will a prize crowd out the love of the work?

Researchers have argued about this for decades, and the honest answer is that it depends how you do it.

In a well-known study, Mark Lepper, David Greene, and Richard Nisbett found that children who expected a prize for drawing later showed less interest in drawing for its own sake than children who received the same prize as a surprise, or no prize at all. Edward Deci had already reported that money as an external reward tended to lower later interest, while verbal reinforcement and positive feedback tended to raise it. A later review of 128 experiments by Deci, Richard Koestner, and Richard Ryan found the same pattern for expected tangible rewards, while positive feedback often enhanced interest.

Judy Cameron, W. David Pierce, and Robert Eisenberger have pushed back, arguing that rewards tied to a clear standard of excellence can support interest rather than drain it.

I take both sides seriously. A bonus, a tool, and a prize are tangible. Praise, a public thank-you, and Driver of the Month are intangible, and they do a different job. A cheap, predictable perk can train the team to work for the perk. A fair reward for real performance, paired with respect and a standard people were actually taught, can do the opposite. It tells a professional that excellence is seen.

Recognition, fairness, and training first

Recognition is not a substitute for a prize, and a prize is not a substitute for being seen. Drivers need both. Driver of the Month works when the criteria are public, the win is real, and the person takes something home — a bonus, a tool, or gear for the route, not only a certificate and a box of donuts.

Fairness is the difference between a game and a grudge. J. Stacy Adams's equity theory is straightforward: people compare what they put in and what they get back with what they see around them. Jason Colquitt and colleagues, in a review of organizational justice research, found that both the fairness of the outcome and the fairness of the process matter. If nobody can explain how the pot is won, it starts to feel like favoritism. Post the rules. Score them the same way every time. Let people check their own standing.

And train first. Then reward. A prize in front of people who have not been taught the standard is not motivation. It is a lottery. Teach the work until a driver can actually be excellent. Then bless the ones who do it.

What a strong DSP incentive can look like

Bring food anyway, when you want to say thank you. Do not confuse the two.

Keep the good work going

I have learned something from every DSP I have been in. The ones that feel human are not softer on standards. They are clearer about them, and they pay excellence back in a form people can use. If more operators shared what is working, this industry would have less of the grind and more of the game.

The Field Guide is free through December 31, 2026. DSP owners can begin on the DSP Owners page. And if you want to compare notes with other drivers and operators, join us in the TLM Discord.

Sources

Back to the blog